Beta-carotene in multivitamins and also the possible chance of cancer of the lung among smokers versus former smokers – tanvetyanon – 2008 – cancer – wiley online library


Our systematic review identified 4 large randomized studies reporting around the aftereffect of beta-carotene and also the incidence of cancer of the lung in high-risk populations. Meta-analysis shown an elevated chance of cancer of the lung connected with beta-carotene supplementation of roughly 24% in the baseline risk noted among participants who have been current smokers. Our survey of multivitamins indicated that almost all contained beta-carotene, although in small dosages. Multivitamins offered to advertise visual health put together to possess a considerably greater dosage of beta-carotene. This finding enhances the concern that excess lung cancers might derive from the standard use of certain multivitamin formulas.

To know the magnitude of the risk, it can help to think about that roughly 50 million Americans regularly consume multivitamins.7 Data in the National Health Interview Survey in the Cdc and Prevention established that roughly 20% of american citizens are current smokers.12 With a rough estimate, roughly 10 millions Americans are current smokers who consume multivitamins. Based on the nation’s Cancer Institute (NCI)’s Surveillance, Epidemiology, and Finish Results database, the incidence of cancer of the lung is roughly 60 per 100,000 within the general population (not always among smokers). Because beta-carotene seems to improve this risk by 24%, a rise in cancer of the lung incidence of 14.4 per 100,000 population should be expected. If these ten million everyone was to eat beta-carotene in the dosage utilized in the chemoprevention study, this could have led to an excessive amount of 1440 cancer of the lung cases every year. Additionally, the dpi could be greater if a person views that the chance of cancer of the lung is 22 occasions greater among male smokers and 12 occasions greater among female smokers compared to risk among their never-smoker counterparts.12

Even though the dosages of beta-carotene within the sample of multivitamins in the present study seem to be substantially less than individuals utilized in the chemoprevention study, one cannot eliminate a straight line dose-risk correlation.3, 4, 10, 11 Inside a large prospective study among French women, the incidence of cancer of the lung elevated as beta-carotene intake elevated, along with a modest dosage of beta-carotene supplementation (believed to become roughly 2.1 mg daily) was discovered to be connected by having an elevated chance of tobacco-related cancers.13 Additionally, for many people who consume a mix of several multivitamin formulations, the cumulative beta-carotene dosage can increase even more. Additionally, prolonged exposure might be significant. The cocarcinogenic aftereffect of beta-carotene seems to originate from being able to exacerbate DNA oxidative damage and modify p53-related pathways of cell proliferation and apoptosis, resulting in the introduction of cancer.14 Because the late 1990s, a correlation between beta-carotene and cancer of the lung continues to be observed.15 A test in ferrets who have been given beta-carotene supplements and uncovered to cigarettes also clearly indicated an acceleration in lung tumorigenesis.16

However, beta-carotene comes with an effectiveness inside a dry kind of age-related macular degeneration (ARMD). This problem, reported to affect roughly .5% of people, is manifested with a gradual lack of vision and could be diagnosed with a dilated eye examination.17 Within the Age-Related Eye Disease Study (AREDS), patients with moderate or advanced ARMD put together to possess a lower chance of disease progression when taking antioxidant supplements including beta-carotene in a dose of 15 mg daily.18 However, you should address the truth that ARMD is definitely an uncommon reason for visual problems in comparison with refractive disorders. Additionally, to the understanding there’s no evidence that patients with early ARMD may benefit from beta-carotene supplementation.19 According to our findings, we feel the public ought to be frustrated from taking beta-carotene supplements to enhance vision with no recommendation using their ophthalmologists.

The present study has lots of limitations. First, within the CARET study, participants also received retinyl palmitate additionally to beta-carotene.4 It’s possible that retinyl palmitate interfered using the risk estimation of beta-carotene, even though it is not likely the observed elevated chance of cancer of the lung resulted exclusively in the administration of retinyl palmitate. Actually, a sizable randomized study of high-dose retinyl palmitate supplementation among patients with stage I cancer of the lung who went through a curative resection established that adjuvant therapy with retinyl palmitate considerably decreased the introduction of a brand new primary cancer of the lung.20 Second, within the ATBC study,3 which in fact had a couple × design, alpha-tocopherol seemed to be administered to roughly 1 / 2 of the participants receiving beta-carotene. An analysis in the ATBC study recommended that alpha-tocopherol were built with a small effect in lessening the incidence of cancer of the lung, although a statistically minor one, which could cause an underestimation of the chance of cancer of the lung within our meta-analysis. Third, the sample of multivitamins in the present study wasn’t comprehensive. However, we feel these were associated with other formulas in the marketplace. Finally, you should highlight these data affect vitamin supplementations which an extrapolation to foods wealthy in beta-carotene for example vegetables and fruit can’t be made.

Following the completing the CARET and ATBC studies, the surplus chance of cancer of the lung and it is connected mortality either endured insignificantly or decreased towards the baseline risk following the stopping of beta-carotene.21, 22 The NCI has printed its conclusions concerning the beta-carotene chemoprevention trials but to the understanding hasn’t made recommendations whether Americans must take supplements.23 The best way forward would be to quit smoking. Because physicians frequently have limited understanding of the items to advise their sufferers regarding nutritional supplementation,24 possibly advice regarding beta-carotene and the chance of cancer of the lung among ongoing smokers also needs to serve this purpose. During our multivitamin survey, we didn’t encounter any disclosure of cancer of the lung risk to any event, even one of the multivitamin brands that contains high-dose beta-carotene.


We thank Dr. I-Min Lee, Harvard School Of Medicine, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, for supplying specifics of the Women’s Health Study.


Article Information


Is Selenium An Antioxidant?